Vi and Vim Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people using the vi and Vim families of text editors. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
I've noticed in bash/shell it highlights $(...) in red, for example:
However, if I change the syntax from ft=sh to ft=bash, it does not do this:
What's the reason for this? Am I doing something wrong with the ft=sh, or why is that highlighted in red when it's a legitimate syntax construct?
This is because the original Bourne shell only understands `...` - the standard $( ... ) syntax was added later. From syntax/sh.vim:
" $() and $(()): {{{1
" $(..) is not supported by sh (Bourne shell). However, apparently
" some systems (HP?) have as their /bin/sh a (link to) Korn shell
" (ie. Posix compliant shell). /bin/ksh should work for those
" systems too, however, so the following syntax will flag $(..) as
" an Error under /bin/sh. By consensus of vimdev'ers!
You can set the variable g:is_bash to tell the sh syntax file that sh is actually bash, if indeed it is actually bash (does sh --version show the Bash version?). Or you can set g:is_posix if sh is POSIX compliant.
g:is_posix should be set by default and g:is_sh should be set only for systems with the broken sh.
/bin/sh is not a symlink to /bin/bash but a copy or hardlink, which is why it's not guessing correctly. Put let g:is_posix = 1 in your vimrc.
Shell originally used only backticks for command substitution:
less `find . -type f`
But these do not nest and suffer from other problems. Bash (and probably ksh, but I’m not up on the history there) used $() as a newer, improved command substitution.
But that explains the difference and why the filetype matters—in fact, the shebang (#! line) matters! If you use /bin/sh, you should only use POSIX sh features. Otherwise, use the path to a known interpreter and use it’s features.
As pointed out in the comments, POSIX allows the newer command substitution, so it should be safe even in sh scripts.
$( ... ) is perfectly fine for POSIX. (See, e.g, even the older versions of the standard.)
sh set ft=bash ?
:let g:is_bash = 1 in your vimrc—:help ft-sh-syntax