How does double star work in vim?

Question

When I run shopt -s globstar; ls -1 tests/**/Helpers/**/*.php in bash I get:

tests/Helpers/Layout.php
tests/Helpers/Link.php
tests/Helpers/LinksPage.php
tests/Helpers/LiqpayRedirect.php
tests/Helpers/LoginPage.php
tests/Helpers/Project.php
tests/Helpers/ProjectsPage.php
tests/Helpers/QueriesPage.php
tests/Helpers/Query.php
tests/Helpers/User.php
tests/Selenium/Helpers/Layout.php
tests/Selenium/Helpers/LinksPage.php
tests/Selenium/Helpers/ProjectsPage.php
tests/Selenium/Helpers/QueriesPage.php
tests/Selenium/Helpers/RegisterPage.php
tests/Selenium/Helpers/User.php

But doing args tests/**/Helpers/**/*.php in vim defines argument list consisting only of files with Selenium in path. Am I doing it wrong? What exactly are the rules? From the docs it sounds like it should work.

Christian Brabandt · Accepted Answer · 2017-01-10 14:02:09Z

5

You can check with echo glob2regpat('tests/**/Helpers/**/*.php') to what regular expression this will be translated. This returns: ^tests[\/].*[\/]Helpers[\/].*[\/].*\.php$, so it will look only for a Helpers directory which is located below any directory underneath the tests directory.

edited Jan 10 '17 at 14:02

answered Jan 10 '17 at 8:50

Christian Brabandt

19.4k34 silver badges53 bronze badges

So this is not particularly true: "** matches anything, including nothing, recurses into directories" More importantly, where's glob2regpath() coming from? My vim says: "Unknown function." – x-yuri Jan 10 '17 at 12:13
update your vim – Christian Brabandt Jan 10 '17 at 12:21
My vim is VIM - Vi IMproved 8.0 (2016 Sep 12, compiled Oct 30 2016 15:29:26) Included patches: 1-55. Maybe that is some distributive-specific function? I'm running Arch Linux. And I can't find it in the docs and Google. – x-yuri Jan 10 '17 at 13:57
the correct function name is glob2regpat (without the h). I had an error in the first version of the answer and have since then updated it. – Christian Brabandt Jan 10 '17 at 14:01
1

@x-yuri no, /.*/ should match an empty path - in POSIX-following environments, any number of consecutive / (except a leading //) is equivalent to a single /. Part of the problem is that while glob2regpat returns a similar looking regex, I don't think the code actually uses regular expressions to check paths. The main problem is apparently the check for expanding ** to an empty path - it only allows it to be done once for a pattern. – muru Jan 12 '17 at 2:49

| show 5 more comments

x-yuri · Accepted Answer · 2017-12-30 01:03:08Z

tl;dr

a bug in vim

how to reproduce/inspect

Build vim from sources with the following patch:

diff --git a/src/misc1.c b/src/misc1.c
index 2d635d677..44ccf4a7a 100644
--- a/src/misc1.c
+++ b/src/misc1.c
@@ -10171,8 +10171,18 @@ unix_expandpath(
     char_u *path,
     int        wildoff,
     int        flags,      /* EW_* flags */
-    int        didstar)    /* expanded "**" once already */
-{
+    int        didstar, int __l)   /* expanded "**" once already */
+{
+FILE *__fp;
+int __i;
+__fp = fopen("../log", "a");
+fprintf(__fp, "%*sunix_expandpath: path: %s, wildoff: %i, flags: %x, didstar: %i\n", __l * 4, "", path, wildoff, flags, didstar);
+if (gap->ga_len) {
+    fprintf(__fp, "%*s    gap:\n", __l * 4, "");
+    for (__i = 0; __i < gap->ga_len; __i++)
+   fprintf(__fp, "%*s        %s\n", __l * 4, "", ((char **)gap->ga_data)[__i]);
+}
+fclose(__fp);
     char_u *buf;
     char_u *path_end;
     char_u *p, *s, *e;
@@ -10274,6 +10284,9 @@ unix_expandpath(
    regmatch.rm_ic = p_fic; /* ignore case when 'fileignorecase' is set */
     if (flags & (EW_NOERROR | EW_NOTWILD))
    ++emsg_silent;
+__fp = fopen("../log", "a");
+fprintf(__fp, "%*s    pat: %s\n", __l * 4, "", pat);
+fclose(__fp);
     regmatch.regprog = vim_regcomp(pat, RE_MAGIC);
     if (flags & (EW_NOERROR | EW_NOTWILD))
    --emsg_silent;
@@ -10292,12 +10305,15 @@ unix_expandpath(
     {
    STRCPY(s, path_end + 1);
    ++stardepth;
-   (void)unix_expandpath(gap, buf, (int)(s - buf), flags, TRUE);
+   (void)unix_expandpath(gap, buf, (int)(s - buf), flags, TRUE, __l + 1);
    --stardepth;
     }

     /* open the directory for scanning */
     *s = NUL;
+__fp = fopen("../log", "a");
+fprintf(__fp, "%*s    inspecting: %s\n", __l * 4, "", *buf == NUL ? "." : buf);
+fclose(__fp);
     dirp = opendir(*buf == NUL ? "." : (char *)buf);

     /* Find all matching entries */
@@ -10308,6 +10324,9 @@ unix_expandpath(
        dp = readdir(dirp);
        if (dp == NULL)
        break;
+__fp = fopen("../log", "a");
+fprintf(__fp, "%*s    entry: %s\n", __l * 4, "", dp->d_name);
+fclose(__fp);
        if ((dp->d_name[0] != '.' || starts_with_dot
            || ((flags & EW_DODOT)
                && dp->d_name[1] != NUL
@@ -10327,7 +10346,7 @@ unix_expandpath(
            STRCPY(buf + len, "/**");
            STRCPY(buf + len + 3, path_end);
            ++stardepth;
-           (void)unix_expandpath(gap, buf, len + 1, flags, TRUE);
+           (void)unix_expandpath(gap, buf, len + 1, flags, TRUE, __l + 1);
            --stardepth;
        }

@@ -10336,12 +10355,15 @@ unix_expandpath(
        {
            /* need to expand another component of the path */
            /* remove backslashes for the remaining components only */
-           (void)unix_expandpath(gap, buf, len + 1, flags, FALSE);
+           (void)unix_expandpath(gap, buf, len + 1, flags, FALSE, __l + 1);
        }
        else
        {
            stat_T  sb;

+__fp = fopen("../log", "a");
+fprintf(__fp, "%*s    found: %s\n", __l * 4, "", buf);
+fclose(__fp);
            /* no more wildcards, check if there is a match */
            /* remove backslashes for the remaining components only */
            if (*path_end != NUL)
@@ -10362,6 +10384,9 @@ unix_expandpath(
            }
 #endif
            addfile(gap, buf, flags);
+__fp = fopen("../log", "a");
+fprintf(__fp, "%*s    added: %s\n", __l * 4, "", buf);
+fclose(__fp);
            }
        }
        }
diff --git a/src/os_unix.c b/src/os_unix.c
index ff0b0e88d..40c1236fe 100644
--- a/src/os_unix.c
+++ b/src/os_unix.c
@@ -6255,7 +6255,7 @@ mch_expandpath(
     char_u *path,
     int        flags)      /* EW_* flags */
 {
-    return unix_expandpath(gap, path, 0, flags, FALSE);
+    return unix_expandpath(gap, path, 0, flags, FALSE, 0);
 }
 #endif

diff --git a/src/proto/misc1.pro b/src/proto/misc1.pro
index 4e299e5f9..50319b6d5 100644
--- a/src/proto/misc1.pro
+++ b/src/proto/misc1.pro
@@ -98,7 +98,7 @@ void fast_breakcheck(void);
 int expand_wildcards_eval(char_u **pat, int *num_file, char_u ***file, int flags);
 int expand_wildcards(int num_pat, char_u **pat, int *num_files, char_u ***files, int flags);
 int match_suffix(char_u *fname);
-int unix_expandpath(garray_T *gap, char_u *path, int wildoff, int flags, int didstar);
+int unix_expandpath(garray_T *gap, char_u *path, int wildoff, int flags, int didstar, int __l);
 void remove_duplicates(garray_T *gap);
 int gen_expand_wildcards(int num_pat, char_u **pat, int *num_file, char_u ***file, int flags);
 void addfile(garray_T *gap, char_u *f, int flags);

$ ./configure CFLAGS='-g -O0 -gdwarf-2 -g3' CXXFLAGS='-g -O0 -gdwarf-2 -g3'
$ make

-g - add debugging information
-O0 - reduce optimizations
-gdwarf-2 -g3 - include information about preprocessor macros

Create test directory:

$ mkdir -p a/b b
$ touch a/b/c b/c
$ tree
.
├── a
│   └── b
│       └── c
└── b
    └── c

Run gdb:

$ rm ../log; gdb --args ../vim/src/vim -u NONE
(gdb) break mch_expandpath
(gdb) r
:args **/b/**/*
(gdb) n

cat ../log:

unix_expandpath: path: **/b/**/*, wildoff: 0, flags: f, didstar: 0
    pat: .*
    (1) unix_expandpath: path: b/**/*, wildoff: 0, flags: f, didstar: 1
        pat: .*
        inspecting: b/
        entry: ..
        entry: c
        unix_expandpath: path: b/c/**/*, wildoff: 4, flags: f, didstar: 1
            pat: .*
            inspecting: b/c/
        unix_expandpath: path: b/c/*, wildoff: 4, flags: f, didstar: 0
            pat: .*
            inspecting: b/c/
        entry: .
    inspecting: .
    entry: a
    unix_expandpath: path: a/**/b/**/*, wildoff: 2, flags: f, didstar: 1
        pat: .*
        inspecting: a/
        entry: b
        unix_expandpath: path: a/b/**/b/**/*, wildoff: 4, flags: f, didstar: 1
            pat: .*
            inspecting: a/b/
            entry: ..
            entry: c
            unix_expandpath: path: a/b/c/**/b/**/*, wildoff: 6, flags: f, didstar: 1
                pat: .*
                inspecting: a/b/c/
            unix_expandpath: path: a/b/c/b/**/*, wildoff: 6, flags: f, didstar: 0
                pat: .*
                unix_expandpath: path: a/b/c/b/*, wildoff: 8, flags: f, didstar: 1
                    pat: .*
                    inspecting: a/b/c/b/
                inspecting: a/b/c/b/
            entry: .
        unix_expandpath: path: a/b/b/**/*, wildoff: 4, flags: f, didstar: 0
            pat: .*
            unix_expandpath: path: a/b/b/*, wildoff: 6, flags: f, didstar: 1
                pat: .*
                inspecting: a/b/b/
            inspecting: a/b/b/
        entry: ..
        entry: .
    (2) unix_expandpath: path: a/b/**/*, wildoff: 2, flags: f, didstar: 0
        pat: .*
        unix_expandpath: path: a/b/*, wildoff: 4, flags: f, didstar: 1
            pat: .*
            inspecting: a/b/
            entry: ..
            entry: c
            found: a/b/c
            added: a/b/c
            entry: .
        inspecting: a/b/
        entry: ..
        entry: c
        unix_expandpath: path: a/b/c/**/*, wildoff: 6, flags: f, didstar: 1
            gap:
                a/b/c
            pat: .*
            inspecting: a/b/c/
        unix_expandpath: path: a/b/c/*, wildoff: 6, flags: f, didstar: 0
            gap:
                a/b/c
            pat: .*
            inspecting: a/b/c/
        entry: .
    entry: b
    unix_expandpath: path: b/**/b/**/*, wildoff: 2, flags: f, didstar: 1
        gap:
            a/b/c
        pat: .*
        inspecting: b/
        entry: ..
        entry: c
        unix_expandpath: path: b/c/**/b/**/*, wildoff: 4, flags: f, didstar: 1
            gap:
                a/b/c
            pat: .*
            inspecting: b/c/
        unix_expandpath: path: b/c/b/**/*, wildoff: 4, flags: f, didstar: 0
            gap:
                a/b/c
            pat: .*
            unix_expandpath: path: b/c/b/*, wildoff: 6, flags: f, didstar: 1
                gap:
                    a/b/c
                pat: .*
                inspecting: b/c/b/
            inspecting: b/c/b/
        entry: .
    unix_expandpath: path: b/b/**/*, wildoff: 2, flags: f, didstar: 0
        gap:
            a/b/c
        pat: .*
        unix_expandpath: path: b/b/*, wildoff: 4, flags: f, didstar: 1
            gap:
                a/b/c
            pat: .*
            inspecting: b/b/
        inspecting: b/b/
    entry: ..
    entry: .

Here we can see that if unix_expandpath (1) had received didstar == 0, as unix_expandpath (2) did, b/c would have matched.

Stack Exchange Network

current community

your communities

more stack exchange communities

How does double star work in vim?

2 Answers 2

tl;dr

how to reproduce/inspect

Your Answer

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged argument-list or ask your own question.

Hot Network Questions

How does double star work in vim?

2 Answers 2

tl;dr

how to reproduce/inspect

Your Answer

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged argument-list or ask your own question.

Related

Hot Network Questions